Wednesday, June 12, 2013

"You can see a lot by just looking" --Yogi Berra

There's a reason Code Jam urges one to look at examples--in this problem, it points you towards the constraint on the Ys that I didn't see because I only considered the most/least significant digit. And now, we'll see whether it can point us at how we might generate noTwos in ascending numerical order.

noTwos, like oneTwos, is based on the result of justOnes. For now, at least, let's ignore the case of an odd number of digits; for them, justOnes simply returns the same values as for the next lower number of digits with a zero in the middle. Now, to take a look at  

putStr $ unlines $ map show (sort (justOnes (2 * n) (min (n - 1) 3))

for some values of n.  Hey, wait; these are palindromes, so let's just look at the top half. After all, the rest is redundant, and it's the top half that determines the ordering.

4:

10
11


6:

100
101
110
111


8:

1000
1001
1010
1011
1100
1101
1110
1111

10:

10000
10001
10010
10011
10100
10101
10110
10111
11000
11001
11010
11011
11100
11101
11110

Oops. 10 breaks the pattern, because you can't have five ones. 12 shows a skip in the middle where there would otherwise be five ones, and as n increases, we'll presumably see more of those.

12:

100000
100001
100010
100011
100100
100101
100110
100111
101000
101001
101010
101011
101100
101101
101110
110000 <-
110001
110010
110011
110100
110101
110110
111000
111001
111010
111100

So, if we pretend these are binary numbers, up to eight digits (total), they go from 10...0 to 11..1. Past eight digits, they go from 10...0 to 11110..0, skipping any value that has more than four ones.

So there is a pattern. How to generate it efficiently?

UPDATE: I'm not sure there is a way; it's tempting to take the interval including all the numbers and then filter (\x -> popCount x <= o + 1) but that's a lot of numbers to generate and then mostly throw away; up at the high end for numbers up to a googol, that'd be around 28 million values that you'd grind out and then throw away all but a few thousand... and then you get to create the palindrome from the top half and switch back to base 10 on top of that. I don't think that's going to cut it... so, back to getting the list of lists of ones to come out in what corresponds to ascending order for the values justOnes generates.

No comments:

Riddler Classic, May 23, 2020—Holy Mackerel!

Another one using Peter Norvig's word list . It turns out that the word "mackerel" has a curious property: there is exactly ...